An Epic Two-Word Response to, “Why aren’t you married yet?”
by Rabbi Josh Yuter
under JBloggers,100hookup,Relationships,Single Life
Nu? So why aren’t you married yet?
I’m guessing if you’re reading this blog you’ve probably gotten this question yourself. Maybe you were in your 20’s when all your friends were getting engaged and married (at least for the first time), or maybe you’re advanced in your 30’s, 40’s, or older. Even if you’ve been lucky enough to have friends and family who are too polite to say this to your face, you might have heard it said about others behind their backs. Even in dating, you might find someone who is more suspicious of someone who has never been married than someone who has been divorced or widowed. The implication is always the same regardless of context; if you haven’t gotten married yet, then there must be something wrong with you.
Singles often have to deal with condescending comments like “Im Yirtzeh Hashem (God willing) by You,” but given the confrontational tone, asking why someone isn’t married is less of a personal inquiry as it is an attack on one’s character. You’re too picky. You’re priorities in life are all wrong. You’re immature. Even if there are substantive emotional challenges with which one is struggling, these would probably not be something people would want to share, especially after being placed on the defensive. There’s virtually no way to answer this question without conceding the premise that, indeed, you should have been married by now, and you must now justify your flawed status in life.
I happen to be a firm believer in Hanlon’s Razor: “Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity.” I’d like to think that people aren’t trying to put others down as much as they are insensitive or ignorant as to the implications of what they’re saying (a recurrent problem in society). Counter-attacking people for their rudeness might feel good in the moment as a way to salvage your dignity, but not only can you come across as unhinged, but you do little to educate well-meaning people as to their insensitivity. On the other hand, not everyone is willing to engage in a detailed conversation, let alone mussar / rebuke, which means an effective response has to be as short as the other person’s attention span.
My suggestion is that the next time someone asks you (or about someone else), “Why aren’t you married yet?” simply respond by asking, “To whom?”
“To whom?”
Yep, and it makes perfect sense.
When someone asks, “why aren’t you married yet” they’re imposing a social stigma, that is the cultural expectation that people ought to get married, and by a certain point in their lives. The problem of course is that people don’t get married to ideas or expectations (excluding metaphors or new-age weddings), they get married to people. Meaning, if someone thinks you ought to have gotten married by now, then it follows there must have been some individual whom you could have married. The set of people anyone could have married can only include the smaller subset of people with whom one has had a relationship and where the other person wanted to get married. After all, in both hookup and secular law, you cannot get married to people who aren’t interested. By definition, getting married is not an individual choice, but a joint decision.
It’s impossible to answer “to whom?” without knowing someone’s life or the details of every previous personal relationship. Only the most socially inept would respond by asking why you didn’t get married to a specific previous significant other, and at a point it would be completely socially acceptable to inform them that your previous relationships are none of their business, or ask them why they think your life would have been better had you married that person.
The main point is that by asking, “to whom?” you not only address the substance of the question directly, but you also reframe the concept of relationships from societal expectations to personal reality. Instead of being forced to defend your life choices or circumstances, you subtly remind people that you’re not just a statistic or nameless interchangeable single person, but that you’re an individual with specific unique experiences. This includes not just finding the right person, but doing so at the right time for both of you. Societal expectations dictate that “getting married” is more important than the quality of the marriage. But while it might not matter to society to whom one gets married, I would hope that to the individual in question it matters a great deal.
So, the next time you find yourself hearing someone ask why you or someone else isn’t married, try these two simple words. You might educate someone while simultaneously validating wherever you happen to be in life.
Subscribe to JBlog
November 27th, 2014 at 5:31 am
Very nice.
Also, “to whom” shifts the subject from “what do I think about this person” to “what can I do to help this person”.
November 27th, 2014 at 7:13 pm
“You’re an individual”
I’m not!
March 20th, 2015 at 1:29 am
It doesn’t really work…If you reply “To whom?”, the answer will be: “Well, don’t you have a girlfriend/boyfriend?”. If you say yes, they will want to know why you don’t want to marry them, if you say no, they will ask why are you single, so you are just extending an awkward conversation.
April 16th, 2015 at 4:42 am
I have to agree with Memeito that to whom doesn’t work. I get asked this question all the time and I am getting tired of it. I don’t want to get married because I am tired of answering to why I am not married. I would like to get married if I believe will bring betterment to my existence. Besides, getting married does not guaranteed that one will stay married. Some people believe that getting married is more important than the actual marriage and I am not one of those people. Making yourself believe that it’s time to get married is a bad recipe for a relationship.
June 28th, 2015 at 10:12 pm
I have often replied, would u like the long version or short version? OR
I would rather be single and eventually meet the right person than be married to the wrong person. Haven’t found Mrs. Right, so I continue working on being Mr. Right.